AIF
  • Home
  • India Service Application
  • US Service Application
  • Senior Fellows Track
  • Meet Our Fellows
  • Alumni Corner
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • Get In Touch
  • FAQ

April 25, 2018

A Survey, a Woman, and a Development Dilemma from Haridwar

tseringlhamo Fellowship
Block Coordinator Rekha Reading the Consent Form in Narsan Block, Haridwar.

Tsering’s Fellowship is made possible by the Rural India Supporting Trust.

Compared to the twists, the turns, and the slow and bumpy climb into the mountainous terrain of my two previous survey districts, the relative ease of navigating Haridwar district’s dusty flat and paved roads was a pleasant surprise. Mini-rickshaw or e-rickshaws ferried us with ease from the main Haridwar-Delhi Highway into the hidden villages miles away from the bustle; shrouded behind rows and rows of rectangular green wheat crops shaded by rows of giant poplar trees, we finally arrived at the village. Along the way, little girls in hijabs and little boys in white caps walk the lonely road towards a white infrastructure. As I stare at the backs of the little crowd as we pass by them, one of the field supervisors mention: “They are headed to the madrasa.”

 

Young Village Girls Escorting Us to the Main Road After Survey.

I would soon discover what a madrasa was. A field supervisor who’s conducting the survey with me approaches me and asks, “Sharing [Tsering], what do write for level of education? She went to the madrasa before menarche.” Surprised to discover another education system—albeit religion based, I didn’t know how to reply because a religious education is nonetheless an education. After consulting with the field team, we found a compromise by estimated the years of madrasa attendance by matching it with the government school’s annual year. However, the cross-cultural miscommunication of the survey language didn’t stop there; although Hindi was the main medium of communication in the previous two districts, Haridwar’s Muslim population spoke Urdu. Despite the vast similarities in Urdu and Hindi, particularly when spoken, the similarities end when written. So, an intelligent and articulate high schooler couldn’t answer the questions asked of her in the written survey—she had to be read the questions aloud.

Conducting Menstrual Hygiene Survey in Narsan Block, Haridwar

Yet on the opposite spectrum, numerous late teens were easily found fetching water, cooking lunch over mud stoves, and tending to the livestock when we did rounds into the villages. It was surprising to find the magnitude of young teenage girls at home during school hours; it served as a huge contrast to the scarcity of young girls at home in villages in the mountains. The common factor that seemed to designate these young girls to this fate was reaching menarche – that first period, the sign of womanhood.  Seen as dangerous to the girl’s innocence and the family reputation to have a menstruating girl going outside the home to attend school, girls quit school upon getting their period. So, bright and young girls sit all day at home doing chores while their male counterparts attend school – thus the opportunity for education and a future denied.

 

MANSI Field Supervisor Rekha of Bhagwanpur Block Explaining to the Villagers about the Menstrual Hygiene Survey.

As much as it bothered me to see these young girls grounded and clipped of their wings, I felt hopeful that within this space that AIF’s Maternal and Newborn Survival Initiative (MANSI) is able to step in and work to empower the women and the community. MANSI’s steadfast commitment brought to fruition reciprocal engagement with their villages. Upon entering the village, young women often flock towards the MANSI field supervisor, greeting her as didi and serving as guides into the village. MANSI’s recognition within the villages speaks volumes about the community building that they have achieved towards promoting health in the rural pockets. Young and old both recognize MANSI and their work; yet, in one of these in field visits, I witnessed the developmental debacle first hand. An older woman in her 50s approached the MANSI field supervisor and me as we were finishing up our surveys with the adolescent girls seated the wooden cots outside. Perhaps jealous or perhaps frustrated by the attention on the younger generation, the older woman asked why we’re conducting the survey. Time again, we explain the reason for the survey, what we intend to do with the survey while offering the woman the consent form to read for herself since it explains the study in much more detail. With merely a glimpse of the form, she flashes the paper towards us and begins her tirade that we NGOs are always helping the young and never helping the old. I have hip problems and back problems too, but do you survey me and offer me help? Mediation and pacifying techniques were not effective to qualm the woman’s rant. Our suggestions of consulting doctors, and even recommending specific doctors, went unheard. Any response on our part only seemed to escalate the woman’s anger and length of her tirade.

Reading of the Consent Form in Bhagwanpur Block, Haridwar District.

 

We quickly gathered our things and thanked the young girls and families for hosting us as we quietly made our exit. This episode reignited for me the larger question of what an NGO’s role is in community development; a question discussed with my fellow AIF Fellows while burning the midnight oil at Orientation and Midpoint. One the one hand, NGOs fill a need like providing for the vulnerable population of rural woman and girls in MANSI’s case. However, on the other hand, are NGOs creating dependency for the communities they work with? The elder woman to me represented the dependency that NGOs can create within the communities they work with.

 

Me Explaining the Consent Form and the Survey

This dependency seems to allow an individual to relinquish their individual responsibility over their well-being. Thus, how can NGOs work to empower their respective communities and provide a needed service, but not create dependency? Going back to my late-night discussions with AIF Fellows, NGOs tend to have entry strategies into communities, but how often do we hear of exit strategies? Is this intentional or by accident? With risk of deviating into the more cynical side of this discussion: are NGOs serving as peddlers of information (to use the words of another AIF Fellow) and serving their own self-interests to stay relevant? Are NGOs in some way exploiting the very people they have committed to serve and empower?

Survey In Progress in Narsan Block, Haridwar with MASNI Block Coordinator and Field Supervisor.

I do not have the answers to these questions, nor have I found enlightenment in the last seven months here. However, what I have discovered through this journey is the ability to pick and probe at the grey areas in the development field—an equally significant skill. Perhaps an easy response to the question of dependency would be to say that we strive to empower the individual towards self-care and self-advocacy. However, that answer risks being simplistic if it doesn’t take into consideration the complicated factors of the cultural, political, and societal context that we work in. As many development professionals know, changing attitude and behaviors can take a lifetime and there are nuances, perhaps subtle in some places, that make such a blanket statement ineffective. So, how do we work within this contradiction?

Author

  • tseringlhamo
    tseringlhamo

    Tsering earned her Bachelor’s of Arts in International Studies from the American University in Washington, DC, focusing on environmental sustainability and global health. Originally intending to pursue a medical education, her volunteer experiences abroad in the hospitals in rural settings inspired her passion for global health and the political ecology of disease. Prior to joining the AIF Clinton Fellowship, Tsering worked as a laboratory associate at Yale New Haven Hospital and interned at an international development NGO. In her free time, Tsering enjoys drawing, traveling, learning new languages and exploring new cultures.

    Tsering's Fellowship is made possibly by the Rural India Supporting Trust.

    View all posts
tseringlhamo

Tsering earned her Bachelor’s of Arts in International Studies from the American University in Washington, DC, focusing on environmental sustainability and global health. Originally intending to pursue a medical education, her volunteer experiences abroad in the hospitals in rural settings inspired her passion for global health and the political ecology of disease. Prior to joining the AIF Clinton Fellowship, Tsering worked as a laboratory associate at Yale New Haven Hospital and interned at an international development NGO. In her free time, Tsering enjoys drawing, traveling, learning new languages and exploring new cultures.

Tsering's Fellowship is made possibly by the Rural India Supporting Trust.

Tags: AIF Clinton Fellowship 2017-18, AIF William J. Clinton Fellowship for Service in India, community empowerment, gender, Maternal and Newborn Survival Initiative, menstrual hygiene management, Uttarakhand

Post navigation

Previous Post Previous
Next PostNext

You Might Also Like

A vibrant representation of a nabungajara (mythical creature from Hindu mythology), which combines elements from nine different animals, adorns an external wall on the Kala Bhoomi campus.
November 13, 2026
Ranga Jadugara: On Learning a Place Through Art
November 10, 2026
The Day a Lunchbox Changed my Understanding of Education
Colorful Navaratri alter
Adjusting to Indian Standard Time™: Time Management in India

Latest Posts

  • A vibrant representation of a nabungajara (mythical creature from Hindu mythology), which combines elements from nine different animals, adorns an external wall on the Kala Bhoomi campus.
    Ranga Jadugara: On Learning a Place Through Art
    November 13, 2026
  • The Day a Lunchbox Changed my Understanding of Education
    November 10, 2026
  • Colorful Navaratri alter
    Adjusting to Indian Standard Time™: Time Management in India
    November 10, 2026

Follow Us

Stay up to date on the latest news and help spread the word.

Support Our Work

Help transform the lives of millions of people in India.

Donate Now  See Your Impact in Motion
AIF-logo-white-300x99

The American India Foundation is a 501[c][3] organization committed to improving the lives of India’s underserved, with a special focus on women, children, and youth.

DONATE NOW
NEW YORK | CALIFORNIA
  • About Us
    • Mission Vision Values
    • History
    • Impact in Motion
    • Programs at a Glance
    • People
    • Knowledge Center
    • News and Updates
    • Blog
    • Financials
  • Our Work
    • Education
      • Digital Equalizer
      • Learning And Migration Program
    • Livelihoods
      • Ability Based Livelihood Empowerment
      • Market Aligned Skills Training
    • Leadership Development
      • Banyan Impact Fellowship
    • Integrated Programs
      • Support Adolescent Health Education & Livelihood Initiative
      • Skilling Nutrition Education and Health
    • Humanitarian Relief
      • AIF COVID-19 Relief Response
      • COVID Rehabilitation Fund
      • The First Million
    • Public Health
      • Maternal And Newborn Survival Initiative
  • Get Involved
    • Explore Our Chapters
    • Join Circle of Hope
    • Become a Young Professional
    • Create a College Chapter
    • Become a Youth Ambassador
    • Become a Corporate Partner
    • Start Your Fundraiser
    • Join a Mission Trip
    • Join an Event
    • AIF Arcade
  • Ways To Give
    • Light A Lamp
    • Donate Crypto
    • Give Stock
    • Give from DAF
    • Become a Monthly Donor
    • Start a Birthday Fundraiser
    • Leave a Legacy
    • Donate in India
    • Contact Us
      • Donor Portal
      • Inquiries
      • Careers
  • Donate Now
    • Give Once
    • Give Monthly
    • Humanitarian Relief
      • Donate to Nepal Flood Relief
      • Donate to Assam Flood Relief
    • Give to the Galas
      • Bay Area Gala
      • New England Gala
      • New York Gala
charity-navigator
gep-logo
guidestar
non-profit-logo
© Copyright 2000-2026 American India FoundationTM is a 501(c)(3) organization (EIN: 13-4159765)
Privacy Policy
  • PRIVACY
  • COOKIES
  • TERMS
  • PRICING
  • API
  • DATA

Follow us:

Subscribe to newsletter

Become a Fundraiser or Donate to Light a LAMP

Privacy & Cookies Notice
We use cookies and similar technologies to collect information and to personalize the site. By continuing to use this site, you consent to the placement of these cookies and similar technologies and to our privacy practices.

Read our updated Privacy Notice to learn more.
Accept all cookies  Cookie Settings
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate. Out of these, the cookies categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of the basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT
55616053293_f0e9c8650d_c
55616127089_e0f11e71d8_c
55614907547_85a67feb8d_c
55615915416_88a4f1bcfa_c
55616052283_0ae34ffa70_c
55616125884_92421a970f_c
55614907782_93773f3a09_c
55616054643_60413bfa1f_c
55614908742_b834e475ff_c
55616128124_3b1605d6c1_c
55616128644_5f7708e2b0_c
55615918406_92f3408182_c
55616331635_3925cb6a26_c
55616055278_52bb8ab3a0_c
55616057133_79fb911de2_c
55615917651_df80b217d8_c
55616056903_cd387ab4c8_c
55616057353_72727dca9d_c
55616333395_785cf5b028_c
55616333590_922d63cbab_c
55326088507_cfb3c39d82_z
55327217314_d3170dfbeb_z
55327418330_706ee45295_z
55326999221_dd05aa938f_z
55327215664_316a7e95a3_z
55327159633_e6611a9578_z
55326086597_bf1f2dafc8_z
55327161938_31321a5d4f_z
55327416140_066c9bbe4b_z
55327216419_f1fd1dc9cb_z
55326994101_e3409674c2_z
55327154373_c75309513b_z
55327156008_5e9316ba57_z
55327002316_48cd65ca3b_z
55327217634_4f1bb2d997_z
55327217854_904e0ea6ee_z
55327217139_28151b7ca8_z
55327002721_13df3dba30_z
55327418650_a3eaf0175d_z
55327417775_25a3efe985_z
55327418585_69454371cc_z
55295022115_495c9bc5d8_b
55293699227_1100d34999_z
55294998903_fcf6276958_z (1)
55295257085_4189543693_z
55293699602_a44b8cf1b3_z (1)
55294998823_22b1f4831f_z
55294844896_a81ccb1846_z (1)
55294611521_e14e12d38c_z
55294999178_1357596fb5_c
55294844896_a81ccb1846_z
55293935307_955ab8d3f0_z
55295085929_402beaf049_z
55294844171_327a23d9d0_z
55294843796_7eee300eef_z
55293934807_983306db41_z
55293934922_97490ccb18_z
55294997918_bd68b50a00_z
55295255930_87514247df_z
55294843206_9ee356b6f9_z
55294842516_c20d7c699a_z
55293932587_eb9c10dc05_z
55294841536_5c7842d9f8_z
55295254900_b32dfbd193_z
55294998903_fcf6276958_z
55293699602_a44b8cf1b3_z
55294845186_3b04736eb0_z
55295254255_0b29cda9a9_z

Start Your Collegiate Alliance Today!

Connect with us to learn more, request a fundraising toolkit, and ask questions about forming a collegiate alliance.

Subscribe for the Newsletter

Subscribe

Keep up with the latest AIF news and updates on our programs, events and campaigns

-

Please share the name and email of the person you would like to recommend:

To automatically download the marketing collateral, please share the following details:

Skip to content
Open toolbar Accessibility Tools

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase TextIncrease Text
  • Decrease TextDecrease Text
  • GrayscaleGrayscale
  • High ContrastHigh Contrast
  • Negative ContrastNegative Contrast
  • Links UnderlineLinks Underline
  • Readable FontReadable Font
  • Reset Reset