Setbacks and Challenges:
A significant challenge that occurred during my Fellowship was the closing of one of CHHIP’s partner schools in 2013. It was a low-cost private school where CHHIP had built a toilet and a water system. When the school closed, I had to work with my team to identify a replacement school right away. Initially, we wanted to partner with whichever school the children had dispersed to. However, the children had dispersed to three different schools. None of the schools ended up being suitable for CHHIP at this point, either due to complicated community politics or lack of interest from school administration. Luckily, we had just recruited control groups schools and were able to convert one of the nearby schools to a partner school in order to continue maximizing our impact.
Our team also had to make the decision of whether or not to reclaim the materials we had used in building the school’s toilets and water system. These facilities had not been built on school land, but rather on the land of a nearby community member who had granted permission for the project. We decided to reclaim as much as the invested materials as we could salvage. This is because there had been a history within that community of money-loaded NGOs freely giving out materials, and we did not want CHHIP to have the reputation of being a gift-giving organization. Problems also arose when our team went to reclaim the materials. Even though we had worked with a school committee member (the actual school principal kept evading us) to fix a date for retrieving everything, the day we arrived 30% of our piping had gone missing. I had to make the decision to not pursue the issue as I felt any accusations would reflect badly on CHHIP, and to instead leave the community without quarrel.
To me, the experience with this school taught me the importance of thoroughly assessing community buy-in before partnering with a school. This school had been chosen in 2011 before I arrived, and had been one of the most difficult schools to work with during my time with CHHIP. As a private school, the administration had a very complicated political relationship with the community, in which CHHIP got entangled. The administration itself also did not seem clear about the boundaries of CHHIP, and often asked me if CHHIP could provide for things that were well outside of the project purview. Moving forward, I hope that CHHIP project staff has the time and human resources to conduct a thorough assessment of the community and school political environments, and that all partners are explicitly aware of what CHHIP can and cannot provide based on the partnership MOU.
Another setback I encountered was the bureaucratic inefficiency and constant turn over of government officials within the newly formed Ghorkhaland Territorial Administration (GTA). I periodically made visits to GTA members and public health officials to advocate for CHHIP and the needs of our partner communities. Many times I would meet and make a plan with an official, only to find that the person had been replaced three months later and our plan abandoned. This happened, for example, with the Secretary of the Public Health Engineering Department, with whom I was working to get the government to build water systems (as required by law!) at two of our government partner schools. In another instance, I tried to access the government’s Free Spectacles Program in order to get glasses for CHHIP children. This scheme was working in the plains but not in the Darjeeling hills. It took a whole year for the block-level medical officers to even become aware of the program, and to begin discussions with me about how to avail the scheme.
Certification of our School Health Activists (SHAs) proved yet another challenge. A lot of our training happens in-house because the information we want our SHAs to provide and the style in which we want them to teach the health curriculum is very specific. However, the fact remains that our SHAs are not certified in any way that is recognized by the government of India. Although CHHIP is careful to have the SHAs only provide interventions for which there is a large body of evidence saying that delivery via community health workers is safe and effective, non-certification leaves CHHIP vulnerable to scrutiny. While working as the project manager, I submitted a project proposal to the North Bengal Medical College in order to receive ethical clearance of our project. We are still waiting for the outcome of this proposal. There were other leads for certification that I pursued during my time with CHHIP that did not come to fruition, and which remain a challenge for future project staff.
Leverage:
As previously mentioned (in Part 1), one of my main projects was to help develop a child mental and developmental health intervention. In addition to designing the intervention, I was tasked with helping to secure funding for its implementation. Michael and I co-authored a grant proposal for submission to the Harvard Dean’s Challenge, which offered a chance to win $70,000. The proposal was selected as a project finalist, and in total we received $12,500 worth of start-up funding.
In September, I participated in the Broadleaf Darjeeling to Kathmandu Charity Bike Ride. I personally raised $2,000 for donation to Broadleaf HEA/CHHIP, and rode a mountain bike with eight other people across the Himalayas to raise awareness of CHHIP’s work.
CHHIP also received more visibility as a result of my partnership building efforts with GTA and public health officials. By the end of my time in Darjeeling, GTA and public health officials were knowledgeable about CHHIP and seemed to have a good impression of the project, especially those officials working at the block level. Block Medical Officers even began recognizing our SHAs.
Reflections and Lessons Learned:
Being a part of Broadleaf Health and Education Alliance, and specifically CHHIP, was an incredibly positive experience for me. Broadleaf HEA’s start-up nature, and CHHIP’s status as a pilot program, gave me a lot of room to help mold the direction of the project. At times the lack of precedent for decisions, proper systems, basic forms, and incompleteness of some of the interventions was frustrating, but overall I appreciated being able to make my own imprint on the project and to be accountable for my decisions and actions. Working with Michael and the rest of Broadleaf HEA’s Board of Directors also gave me an understanding of how NGOs are run behind the scenes, and what the leadership decision-making process is like. I learned how alike NGO expansion plans are to business models, and how to conduct myself when pitching to money-minded donors.
Implementing CHHIP has also helped me better understand the crucial role community health workers play in closing the public health human resources gap in India, and in making current health services more accessible for remote and marginalized communities. The services that CHHIP provides are not routinely undertaken by the public health system at the local level, mostly because there are very few trained doctors placed near remote villages. This is especially true in Darjeeling, where there is a preference is for local Nepali speaking health professionals and where there aren’t any government trained ASHAs and ANMs. The delivery of basic services can be shifted from higher-tier doctors whose skills may be better utilized treating complex cases, to community health workers such as the CHHIP SHAs.
Secondly, there are several barriers to care ranging from the economic to the social. Sometimes families can’t afford medicines or specialized treatment. Sometimes people don’t know what health services are available, where to get them, or how to navigate the health system. Other times language and cultural barriers prevent care. In one example, a CHHIP child was taken to Nepal because the mother felt more comfortable taking the child to a Nepali speaking facility for surgery rather than to the nearby Indian city of Siliguri where the services are free but the doctors only speak Hindi or Bengali. Community health workers cannot rectify all these problems, but they can help mitigate some of them but providing information to community members, accompanying people to clinics for support, and mobilizing the larger community to take up donations to help pay for specialized services an individual could never afford.
Working with the CHHIP SHAs was a great experience as I watched and helped mentor their professional growth. Their commitment to learning the health materials and dedication to their communities was truly inspirational. Through qualitative feedback with the SHAs, school staff, and other community members, I do believe that the SHAs developed higher social standing in their communities, and that they became trusted health advisors. The SHAs were also very conscious of their professional limitations, and were careful to refer to the PHC or other health professionals concerning cases they were not trained to treat.
I experienced major professional and personal growth as a result of being CHHIP’s project lead. This was my first professional experience as project manager, and it took time to evolve a leadership style suited to the conditions and staff in Darjeeling. Delegating tasks, making definite decisions, and managing professional and personal boundaries with my colleagues was an ongoing process thorough the fellowship. Personally, I found that working with my Indian colleagues demanded a sort of indirectness at times, when my first inclination was to be blunt and to-the-point. I thought I was rather culturally sensitiveness and discreet, but after a personal incidence in which I unknowingly offended my landlord, I realized that there is always room for more adaptation and growth. At the same time, working with Michael and the rest of the U.S.-based Broadleaf HEA team has encouraged me to push for efficiency, effectiveness, and boldness in a sector renowned for inefficiency, ineffectiveness, and timidity. Overall, the Fellowship has given me an opportunity to practice integration into new environments, while staying true to myself and adding an outside perspective that can help catalyze innovation and positive change.

