AIF
  • Home
  • India Service Application
  • US Service Application
  • Senior Fellows Track
  • Meet Our Fellows
  • Alumni Corner
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • Get In Touch
  • FAQ

January 25, 2019

Foregrounding Adversity: Dissecting ‘Pathos,’ a Mode of Persuasion

Christopher Scott Carpenter Fellowship

Recently, while browsing the internet on my cell phone I was met with an advertisement. In it we see a young girl, in infancy, wrapped in what appears to be a hospital gown and placed on what we can assume to be a hospital bed. This young girl is implied to be in mid-wail, her mouth agape in anguish. Her eyes are clenched in pain and her hand is outstretched, perhaps searching for something to hold. She’s alone on the bed; neither parent nor doctor can be seen. She’s been given a name: “Mulla.”

Still: author

It struck me that the camera looks down on this girl. Spatially, the audience is instructed to literally “look down” on her – to pity her. The advertisement wants to place us in the position of a bedside hospital visitor. The open mouth, in particular, is powerful – do we pick her up and comfort her to end her crying, or do we walk away?

What’s more is the text that accompanies the image, which echoes a mother’s final desperate plea for relief: “Allah, please save my daughter,” it reads. Further down: “Please help.” It thus places the burden on us, the readers, to intervene and save a young girl’s life. This is what advertisers have deemed the “call to action” – the resonating directive to do a certain thing as soon as possible. The call here is strong because the advertisement unabashedly attempts to provoke a sympathetic response from the audience through its combination of text and photograph.

The Greek philosopher Aristotle called this appeal to emotion “pathos,” which is “[the] awakening [of] emotion in the audience so as to induce them to make the judgment desired” (Aristotle and Kennedy 119). Pathos is one of the three Aristotelian “modes of persuasion,” along with “ethos” (the appeal to expertise and endorsement) and “logos” (the appeal to statistics and facts), and of the three it is arguably the most potent (Aristotle and Kennedy 119). Some of the most effective campaigns in recent memory were driven by pathos: for American audiences, the Sarah McLachlan-narrated spot for the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in which her song “Angel” is played over a montage of animals locked in cages has entered the collective cultural consciousness and has been parodied and referenced in other media numerous times. The fact of the matter is that the spot helped raise $30 million for the ASPCA within two years of being aired (Strom), which is a landmark achievement in non-profit fundraising.

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu_JqNdp2As

Notice the similarities between the two approaches: the subjects, helpless creatures, are isolated and alone; the facial expressions are that of anguish; and the camera angles, the audience’s viewpoints into the respective narratives of adversity, are from above and angled downward, reinforcing the pity we are meant to feel and the power we have over their circumstances. Both are potent. I’m sure each elicited sympathy in you to some extent as well.

Research confirms this notion. Our human brains are hardwired to process emotions faster than conscious thoughts, so much so that “emotions process sensory input in only one-fifth the time our conscious, cognitive brain takes to assimilate that same input” (Hill 19). The response isn’t just quicker; it’s also stronger, such that “[the] emotional reaction to a stimulus resounds more loudly in our brain than does our rational response, triggering the action to follow” (Hill 19).  In a further study, researchers using a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) machine found audiences use the “emotive” parts of the brain, rather than the logical, when evaluating brands (Murray). This is the basis of the emotional gut reaction you may have felt viewing the advertisements, the same gut reaction that propelled the ASPCA to immense success in their fundraising efforts.

As a result, visions of young people embroiled in tragedy and adversity are a common approach to advertising in the development sector. After all, it’s an easy sell: many NGOs work directly with and for people who, every day, face debilitating adversity, and it is important to convey to audiences what this adversity looks like, and to show the need for change. Notice how in each the camera is, again, always aimed downward at the subjects of the shots, forcing them to look up to you, the audience, implying in each a kind of longing gaze.

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMuiW1PRx6c
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XozrqJHA-yI
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hmdORdGzbk

Sometimes this insistence on adversity, however, rings manipulative for audiences; it’s when the illumination of an issue becomes exploitation. It’s important to foreground adversity; what matters most is how this is accomplished within the interplay between organization and audience.

FOREGROUNDING ADVERSITY

Crucial to the employment of pathos in advertising is the consideration of the role these emotions play in the larger narrative of the organization’s values. Misjudging the extent to which these emotions can be tapped into – or even which emotions to tap into – can lead to narrative media that feels calculated and inauthentic. In an oft-cited example, American insurance company Nationwide experienced severe backlash when it released a commercial that blindsided audiences with a last-second plot twist that revealed the young narrator of the commercial had actually been dead the whole time, the victim of a preventable accident. It was a shocking amplification of adversity that left many scratching their heads. (Miller)

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bpl10G6O_lI

In a conversation with Contently, Graeme Newell, the founder of 602 Communications, said, “One key component to successful emotional advertising is to find and capitalize on the core value of the brand, not just reach blindly for an emotional reaction” (Miller). These emotions need to serve a larger narrative and need to consider the relationship the audience may have with their media; otherwise, if too blatant, it undermines the emotional intelligence of the audience. If the light shines too brightly, in other words, the shadows of nuance and details are washed out, and the picture is lost.

To foreground adversity is to lead with it – to not only acknowledge it, but to embrace it and let it inform the narrative thrust of the stories we tell. When foregrounding adversity, and thus applying the mechanism that elicits an emotional response, it then follows that adversity can’t simply be presented for the sake of itself. In working to tell the stories of the young people involved in Dream a Dream, we developed a paradigm in addressing the adversity that, in its many shapes and forms and specific to each individual context, is an important component of those stories. In many ways, reducing a story to a single adversarial struggle is a disservice to the complex humanity that faces that struggle. A person can’t be defined by just one element of their existence, especially if that element is beyond their control, as is the case in many of the stories we hope to share.

As a result, the stories we tell present a reality containing adversity, rather than adversity that comprises reality. We trust the audience to have the emotional intelligence to engage with the content, its emotional framework, and its intended outcome without presenting any one element for the sake of itself. In “A Recipe to Thrive,” a short film we produced about a young man involved in Dream a Dream who is using his passion and talents for cooking to overcome adversity and thrive, we see him in his context, which helps illuminate the adversity he faces.

Still: “A Recipe to Thrive,” Dream a Dream.

He comes from a single-income family, his father having suffered an accident several years ago that left him unable to work. This pushed him toward a career he was not passionate about for the sake of a safe income. In terms of the film, instead of the longing gaze we chose to simply observe his reality, rather than emphasize adversity: the kitchen is modest, even meager; the ingredients are few. The imagery speaks to a larger narrative, of a young man taking control of his life by pursuing his passion and utilizing the resources provided him by Dream a Dream (Carpenter).

Still: “A Recipe to Thrive,” Dream a Dream

In another sequence we capture the work being done by his mother to make ends meet for her children. She’s become a flower seller, working in markets and on the streets. Her gaze is never forced upwards; in fact, despite the fact that she’s seated on the ground amongst her materials, we watch her at eye-level as she twists twine around the flower stems and wraps the garlands into beautiful spirals. The process alone is enough to convey the struggles she faces and the adversity she is working to overcome for the sake of her family. The adversity is foregrounded – it certainly isn’t hidden – and that is enough (Carpenter).

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu_JqNdp2As

PATHOS CAN’T JUST BE PITY

Graeme Newell, in his conversation with Contently, also advises content creators to “strategically resolve negative emotions and leave audiences with a positive takeaway” (Miller). While the Sarah McLachlan spots for the ASPCA certainly tug at the heartstrings with images of animals behind the bars of cages, the narrative resolves with feelings of hope as officers and veterinarians ultimately protect and care for the animals (ASPCA). The adversity, then, isn’t there for the sake of itself so as to elicit an emotional response; it’s a means to an end, to a larger story, that more authentically and organically calls audiences to act. Pure adversity can be overwhelming and distancing; like with any good mainstream story, resolution has its value and its place.

I think the disconnect may come from the assumption, on the part of the content creators and storytellers, that if resolution is shown then audiences will see no need to get involved, and will thus lose interest. Echoing the words of Newell, positivity needs to be manifested in some way to show the path of change and improvement.

The Dream a Dream paradigm, as we’ve come to explore it through produced digital content, is young person-centric and dignified. It aims to capture the hope of a young person navigating their own adversity and, through the education and implementation of life skills, thrive. It’s important to enter the headspace of a brighter future, of a tomorrow better than today, because adversity is universal, and people will face some form every day. The opportunities for improvement and solutions and feelings of confidence, against the realities of adversity, are much fewer and farer between; these are what I see as the main ingredient to a pathos-driven campaign.

In the final months of 2018 Dream a Dream initiated a fundraising campaign under the banner “A Chance to Thrive.” With it as a guiding light, the young person-centric paradigm shone through every aspect of the campaign.

Source: https://www.facebook.com/dreamadream.org

The young man in the photograph stands with dignity and confidence. He isn’t gazing upward toward the audience, nor is the audience looking down on him. He is someone who, in his life, faces adversity, but he’s doing it with his eyes toward the horizon, toward a dream and a goal. There is a mutual sense of empowerment between him and the audience; a dignified example of what someone can achieve if given the chance – that chance, of course, coming from the support the campaign sought to secure. The campaign was a total success, shooting past the fundraising expectations and contributing greatly to the efforts of Dream a Dream in Bangalore and beyond.

The beauty of storytelling in its many forms is that it is entirely subjective, both in approach and response. No one approach is superior to any other, and each can be successful in its own way. These are simply my thoughts as I engage during my Fellowship with results-oriented storytelling in the development sector.

I personally think this…

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1hmdORdGzbk

…should be this…

 

Works Cited:

  1. Aristotle, and George Alexander Kennedy. (1991) Aristotle On Rhetoric: A Theory of Civic Discourse. New York: Oxford University Press.
  2. Carpenter, Christopher Scott, director. A Recipe To Thrive. Dream a Dream, 2018.
  3. Hill, Dan. Emotionomics: Leveraging Emotions for Business Success. Kogan Page Ltd., 2010.
  4. Miller, Carly. “The Dangerous Power of Emotional Advertising.” Contently,  14 Apr. 2016. Accessed at: contently.com/2016/04/14/dangerous-power-emotional-advertising.
  5. Murray, Peter Noel. “How Emotions Influence What We Buy.” Psychology Today, 26 Feb. 2013. Accessed at:  www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/inside-the-consumer-mind/201302/how-emotions-influence-what-we-buy.
  6. Strom, Stephanie. “Ad Featuring Singer Proves Bonanza for the A.S.P.C.A.” The New York Times, 25 Dec. 2008. Accessed at: www.nytimes.com/2008/12/26/us/26charity.html?_r=1.
  7.  “ASPCA.” YouTube, 3 July 2007. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu_JqNdp2As.

Author

  • Christopher Scott Carpenter
    Christopher Scott Carpenter

    Christopher graduated magna cum laude from the University of Southern California (USC), where he earned degrees in Film & Television Production and Cognitive Science, and a Minor in Advertising. Throughout his career, he has sought and created partnerships between film technologies and social advocacy to enact positive change. He co-wrote and co-directed “Destination: SLC,” a documentary exploring the experiences of a Kenyan refugee living in Salt Lake City, Utah, which entered the film festival circuit and won regional awards. While at USC, Chris served as the Director of Marketing and Videographer for Program Board, a collective of advocacy groups representing the diverse student populations of USC. Chris conducted research in Beijing, Kaifeng, and Shanghai, China, analyzing the role and influence of globalism in consumer culture. He also served as Team Leader and Student Coordinator for the USC Volunteer Center’s Alternative Winter Break trip to Thailand, utilizing media campaigns to secure funding and supplies for the trip. Chris was elected to Phi Beta Kappa and Mortar Board, and was a member of the Sigma Alpha Mu Fraternity. Upon graduation, he lived and worked in Tokyo, Japan, for Ashinaga, an NGO focused on the education and social rehabilitation of orphaned students, developing and producing media campaigns. Most recently, Chris completed a graduate-level filmmaking certificate course at the Film and TV School of the Academy of Performing Arts in Prague, Czech Republic.

    View all posts
christopher-scott-carpenter

Christopher graduated magna cum laude from the University of Southern California (USC), where he earned degrees in Film & Television Production and Cognitive Science, and a Minor in Advertising. Throughout his career, he has sought and created partnerships between film technologies and social advocacy to enact positive change. He co-wrote and co-directed “Destination: SLC,” a documentary exploring the experiences of a Kenyan refugee living in Salt Lake City, Utah, which entered the film festival circuit and won regional awards. While at USC, Chris served as the Director of Marketing and Videographer for Program Board, a collective of advocacy groups representing the diverse student populations of USC. Chris conducted research in Beijing, Kaifeng, and Shanghai, China, analyzing the role and influence of globalism in consumer culture. He also served as Team Leader and Student Coordinator for the USC Volunteer Center’s Alternative Winter Break trip to Thailand, utilizing media campaigns to secure funding and supplies for the trip. Chris was elected to Phi Beta Kappa and Mortar Board, and was a member of the Sigma Alpha Mu Fraternity. Upon graduation, he lived and worked in Tokyo, Japan, for Ashinaga, an NGO focused on the education and social rehabilitation of orphaned students, developing and producing media campaigns. Most recently, Chris completed a graduate-level filmmaking certificate course at the Film and TV School of the Academy of Performing Arts in Prague, Czech Republic.

Tags: adversity, advertising, AIF, AIF Clinton Fellowship 2018-19, AIF William J. Clinton Fellowship for Service in India, american india foundation, aspiration, Bangalore, community, dignity, dream, dream a dream, education, ethos, fellowship, goal, hope, india, Karnataka, Life skills, logos, NGO, NGOs, non-profit, pathos, service, storytelling, thriving, Youth Development

Post navigation

Previous Post Previous
Next PostNext

You Might Also Like

A vibrant representation of a nabungajara (mythical creature from Hindu mythology), which combines elements from nine different animals, adorns an external wall on the Kala Bhoomi campus.
November 13, 2026
Ranga Jadugara: On Learning a Place Through Art
November 10, 2026
The Day a Lunchbox Changed my Understanding of Education
Colorful Navaratri alter
Adjusting to Indian Standard Time™: Time Management in India

Latest Posts

  • A vibrant representation of a nabungajara (mythical creature from Hindu mythology), which combines elements from nine different animals, adorns an external wall on the Kala Bhoomi campus.
    Ranga Jadugara: On Learning a Place Through Art
    November 13, 2026
  • The Day a Lunchbox Changed my Understanding of Education
    November 10, 2026
  • Colorful Navaratri alter
    Adjusting to Indian Standard Time™: Time Management in India
    November 10, 2026

Follow Us

Stay up to date on the latest news and help spread the word.

Support Our Work

Help transform the lives of millions of people in India.

Donate Now  See Your Impact in Motion
AIF-logo-white-300x99

The American India Foundation is a 501[c][3] organization committed to improving the lives of India’s underserved, with a special focus on women, children, and youth.

DONATE NOW
NEW YORK | CALIFORNIA
  • About Us
    • Mission Vision Values
    • History
    • Impact in Motion
    • Programs at a Glance
    • People
    • Knowledge Center
    • News and Updates
    • Blog
    • Financials
  • Our Work
    • Education
      • Digital Equalizer
      • Learning And Migration Program
    • Livelihoods
      • Ability Based Livelihood Empowerment
      • Market Aligned Skills Training
    • Leadership Development
      • Banyan Impact Fellowship
    • Integrated Programs
      • Support Adolescent Health Education & Livelihood Initiative
      • Skilling Nutrition Education and Health
    • Humanitarian Relief
      • AIF COVID-19 Relief Response
      • COVID Rehabilitation Fund
      • The First Million
    • Public Health
      • Maternal And Newborn Survival Initiative
  • Get Involved
    • Explore Our Chapters
    • Join Circle of Hope
    • Become a Young Professional
    • Create a College Chapter
    • Become a Youth Ambassador
    • Become a Corporate Partner
    • Start Your Fundraiser
    • Join a Mission Trip
    • Join an Event
    • AIF Arcade
  • Ways To Give
    • Light A Lamp
    • Donate Crypto
    • Give Stock
    • Give from DAF
    • Become a Monthly Donor
    • Start a Birthday Fundraiser
    • Leave a Legacy
    • Donate in India
    • Contact Us
      • Donor Portal
      • Inquiries
      • Careers
  • Donate Now
    • Give Once
    • Give Monthly
    • Humanitarian Relief
      • Donate to Nepal Flood Relief
      • Donate to Assam Flood Relief
    • Give to the Galas
      • Bay Area Gala
      • New England Gala
      • New York Gala
charity-navigator
gep-logo
guidestar
non-profit-logo
© Copyright 2000-2026 American India FoundationTM is a 501(c)(3) organization (EIN: 13-4159765)
Privacy Policy
  • PRIVACY
  • COOKIES
  • TERMS
  • PRICING
  • API
  • DATA

Follow us:

Subscribe to newsletter

Become a Fundraiser or Donate to Light a LAMP

Privacy & Cookies Notice
We use cookies and similar technologies to collect information and to personalize the site. By continuing to use this site, you consent to the placement of these cookies and similar technologies and to our privacy practices.

Read our updated Privacy Notice to learn more.
Accept all cookies  Cookie Settings
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate. Out of these, the cookies categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of the basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT
55616053293_f0e9c8650d_c
55616127089_e0f11e71d8_c
55614907547_85a67feb8d_c
55615915416_88a4f1bcfa_c
55616052283_0ae34ffa70_c
55616125884_92421a970f_c
55614907782_93773f3a09_c
55616054643_60413bfa1f_c
55614908742_b834e475ff_c
55616128124_3b1605d6c1_c
55616128644_5f7708e2b0_c
55615918406_92f3408182_c
55616331635_3925cb6a26_c
55616055278_52bb8ab3a0_c
55616057133_79fb911de2_c
55615917651_df80b217d8_c
55616056903_cd387ab4c8_c
55616057353_72727dca9d_c
55616333395_785cf5b028_c
55616333590_922d63cbab_c
55326088507_cfb3c39d82_z
55327217314_d3170dfbeb_z
55327418330_706ee45295_z
55326999221_dd05aa938f_z
55327215664_316a7e95a3_z
55327159633_e6611a9578_z
55326086597_bf1f2dafc8_z
55327161938_31321a5d4f_z
55327416140_066c9bbe4b_z
55327216419_f1fd1dc9cb_z
55326994101_e3409674c2_z
55327154373_c75309513b_z
55327156008_5e9316ba57_z
55327002316_48cd65ca3b_z
55327217634_4f1bb2d997_z
55327217854_904e0ea6ee_z
55327217139_28151b7ca8_z
55327002721_13df3dba30_z
55327418650_a3eaf0175d_z
55327417775_25a3efe985_z
55327418585_69454371cc_z
55295022115_495c9bc5d8_b
55293699227_1100d34999_z
55294998903_fcf6276958_z (1)
55295257085_4189543693_z
55293699602_a44b8cf1b3_z (1)
55294998823_22b1f4831f_z
55294844896_a81ccb1846_z (1)
55294611521_e14e12d38c_z
55294999178_1357596fb5_c
55294844896_a81ccb1846_z
55293935307_955ab8d3f0_z
55295085929_402beaf049_z
55294844171_327a23d9d0_z
55294843796_7eee300eef_z
55293934807_983306db41_z
55293934922_97490ccb18_z
55294997918_bd68b50a00_z
55295255930_87514247df_z
55294843206_9ee356b6f9_z
55294842516_c20d7c699a_z
55293932587_eb9c10dc05_z
55294841536_5c7842d9f8_z
55295254900_b32dfbd193_z
55294998903_fcf6276958_z
55293699602_a44b8cf1b3_z
55294845186_3b04736eb0_z
55295254255_0b29cda9a9_z

Start Your Collegiate Alliance Today!

Connect with us to learn more, request a fundraising toolkit, and ask questions about forming a collegiate alliance.

Subscribe for the Newsletter

Subscribe

Keep up with the latest AIF news and updates on our programs, events and campaigns

-

Please share the name and email of the person you would like to recommend:

To automatically download the marketing collateral, please share the following details:

Skip to content
Open toolbar Accessibility Tools

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase TextIncrease Text
  • Decrease TextDecrease Text
  • GrayscaleGrayscale
  • High ContrastHigh Contrast
  • Negative ContrastNegative Contrast
  • Links UnderlineLinks Underline
  • Readable FontReadable Font
  • Reset Reset