So this point in our project cycle is the end of the school year, so we have a whole lot of data entry, analysis, and report writing to do. Each year we give all of the students a pre and post health knowledge test and a pre and post attitude and behavior survey. The purpose of these is to see if the students learned anything new throughout the year and if it has had an affect on their health behaviors. We give it to the students at our control group and partner schools to see if the changes is score can be attributed to our program or to random other things happening in the community. Then we analyze the data and see if there is a statistically significant difference between the two groups. This is an incredibly boring and time consuming process, but it is part of what all organizations have to do to make sure that their programs are working. One of the fact of NGO life as it were. But as I am sitting here reading the exams and grading them, I feel like I am researching the lives of my students. The attitude and behavior survey asks them about washing their hands, cleaning, and what they eat. Basically it asks them what they do on a day to day basis to improve their health. It also asks for them to list three things they like about themselves. The difficulty of explaining this concept to the students has been surprising. You ask the average American child what they like about themselves, and they will be able to come up with a long list. The children here end up saying things they like to do, to eat, or nothing at all. It is strange and a little sad to me that our children can’t process the thought of self-esteem. I wish I could talk to them about it, but my Nepali is rudimentary at best, so we can’t communicate with one another. But through these exams and surveys, I think I am getting to know the CHHIP students a little bit better. And hopefully I will be able to remember that as I am analyzing numbers and writing reports. They aren’t just numbers, they are children that I have met and that I am slowly getting to know throughout my time here. I think this is something that all monitoring and evaluation professionals should remember. Many of them might not get the opportunity to meet the people that their program hurts with, but if they remember that the numbers are people, it will be like they are meeting them and learning a lot about them.
Megan
Your post raises a question for me. Do the Indian kids feel comfortable about who they are in totality and do not feel it necessary to pick on any individual item they feel good about themselves. Contrastingly in the US because we are constantly encouraged to think highly of ourselves because ” being a winner” is so important that we need self reiteration of strengths . Recall a study about ten years ago which showed that US Pupils had higher self esteem than Indian ones ( calculated based on US methodology) but not significantly higher.
If it is a matter of inability to voice personal “feel good” factors can you gauge the actual self esteem by giving them a list from say a group of US children and ask them how they feel with respect to those parameters about themselves .
Sridar