Urbanization After Paris, Part 1

“India will be the first major country to experience urbanization after the Paris Agreement.” 

I was attending a panel called “Urban Skylines of the Future” at the 2020 Jaipur Literature Festival, when Professor Navroz K. Dubash from India’s Centre for Policy Research made this statement. The panel was hosted in response to a UN report that claimed that by 2050, 35% of the world’s urban population growth will happen in Nigeria, China, and India, with India responsible for the greatest portion of that growth. 

Earlier in the day, I attended a session, also featuring Professor Dubash, with journalist David Wallace-Wells, author of the 2017 landmark climate piece, “The Uninhabitable Earth.” Last year, Wallace-Wells released a full book edition of the piece, which paints, in heavily researched, terrifying detail, the worst case (but certainly not impossible) scenario if humans do not act fast to slash our carbon emissions, protect biodiversity, and take the steps available to us to prevent runaway climate change. 

These two sessions put into stark relief a question that I have been wrestling with since I first arrived and started working in India a few months ago—can a fast-growing country like India develop both quickly and sustainably? Or put more fundamentally: are economic development and environmental sustainability even compatible? 

Disclaimer: I do not have a definitive answer to these questions. But from what I learned from these speakers, and from my own research, the answer is something like: Maybe not, but we have to find a way to make them compatible. 

Which brings me back to Professor Dubash’s statement—“India will be the first major country to experience urbanization after the Paris Agreement.” Whether your source material is the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s landmark 2018 report (which gives us roughly a decade to make major changes if we are to avert the most serious consequences of climate change by limiting temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius), Mr. Wallace-Wells’ book (which shows us a near-future world with social and ecological collapse), or some other research-based publication, the urgency of climate change is clear. But as I’ve quickly learned—whether in conversations with peers and coworkers, through readings, or through the panels I attended—the fair question comes up about who bears the responsibility for solving the climate crisis? 

We can look at the list of countries most responsible for the historical emissions that are largely responsible for the climate crisis—the top 10 being the US, China, Russia, Germany, UK, Japan, France, India, Canada, and Ukraine. (1)  Contrasting this to the 10 countries most impacted by climate change today—Japan, Philippines, Germany, Madagascar, India, Sri Lanka, Kenya, Rwanda, Canada, Fiji (2)—we see some overlap, but generally, climate change can be perceived as a problem caused by the Global North that devastates the Global South. As these countries work to develop and urbanize, is it the responsibility of poorer, more vulnerable countries to solve a problem they didn’t create? 

This table from a 2020 Climate Risk Briefing by GermanWatch shows the countries most impacted by Climate Change in 2018. (Citation: 2)

In fact, when we look to the behaviors of small island nations, we can see that they are clearly recognize the existential threat that climate change poses to them, and have made major commitments when it comes to reducing their emissions, greening their infrastructure, and making sure they are designing for a resilient future. (3) Their ability to change the global trajectory, however, is unfortunately limited, unless the most major polluters step up and change their ways. 

This map, also from GermanWatch, shows the historically most impacted countries, and current climate risk by country. (Citation: 2)

But this is where India has a particularly interesting role to play: it holds the unfortunate distinction of being both one of the world’s fastest growing and most major polluters, and one of the countries most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. In fact, during Mr. Wallace-Wells and Mr. Dubash’s panel, one of the panelists shared the fact that India will bear a disproportionate burden of the world’s climate impact because of its population density, geography, and inequality (he cited 25% of the world’s total impact, a number I was not able to verify for this piece).

New Delhi’s dense, bustling streets highlight the need to build green infrastructure in Indian cities. (Citation: 5)

To me—in this sobering position, there is an exciting possibility for India. Unlike many countries which have largely completed their urbanization, India has the opportunity to create a blueprint for what it looks like for a massive country to urbanize in an era where carbon neutrality is an imperative. India has to find ways of tackling climate risks—extreme heat waves, drought, air pollution, floods and other natural disasters—while addressing major urbanization realities like transportation, energy, construction, supply chain management, and sanitation. (4)

If India is able to innovate its way into a low to no carbon future, imagine the precedent it could set for other countries—big and small, high and low polluting—all across the world. While climate change will, over time, impact all of the top 10 polluters on the list, India must address the problem with an even greater sense of urgency given the impact its already having on its population (just look at 2019’s flooding, heat waves, delayed monsoon, and more). Beyond solving a problem for its own people, India could help safeguard the futures for other countries as well—stepping into an even greater international leadership role. 

India’s cities are quickly transforming with new construction.
(Citation: 6)

So what is India doing to take advantage of this unique opportunity, and what are the challenges it is facing along the way? In Part Two of this post—Urbanization After Paris—I’ll feature some of the innovative work happening across India to build more resilient cities and start creating this blueprint for the future.

References

  1. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/apr/21/countries-responsible-climate-change
  2. https://germanwatch.org/sites/germanwatch.org/files/20-2-01e%20Global%20Climate%20Risk%20Index%202020_10.pdf
  3. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/09/island-nations-maldives-climate-change/
  4. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-45949323
  5. https://india.uitp.org/articles/delhi-will-be-world-biggest-city-2028
  6. https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/6rDQ6FfzmC3nbW5xZycrIK/Opinion–Indias-now-a-land-of-cities-not-villages.html

Anjali is serving as an American India Foundation (AIF) Clinton Fellow with Frontier Markets in Jaipur, Rajasthan. For her Fellowship project, she is creating a distribution model that is cost effective and efficient in providing rural households with access to clean energy products through a network of rural women entrepreneurs. Anjali graduated with a degree in American Studies, where she focused on how the design of the build environment—from school buildings to housing developments to monuments—shapes culture and society. While at Yale, she launched a consulting practice that paired Yale business students with undergraduate organizations to improve their strategy, infrastructure, and ultimately, impact. For the past five years, she helped grow The Future Project—a non-profit organization focused on helping young people develop the purpose and agency to build a better future for themselves. After wearing a variety of hats at the organization, Anjali found her professional passion as the company’s vice president of innovation, leading teams to incubate and launch new products, programs, and services to increase reach, quality, and economic sustainability. Inspired by her time working with young people, Anjali plans to devote the next phase of her career to pursuing this purpose through environmental work—developing clean and sustainable products, services, and systems that will ensure that we have a healthy planet for our young people to inherit. Through the AIF Clinton Fellowship, Anjali is excited to dive into the world of clean energy and rural empowerment, reconnect with her Indian heritage, and spend time with her grandmothers who she hasn’t seen in years.

You Might Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Us

Stay up to date on the latest news and help spread the word.

AMERICAN INDIA FOUNDATION IS A REGISTERED 501 (C)(3) Charity. © 2020
NEW YORK | CALIFORNIA | NEW DELHI

Privacy Policy

Get Involved

Our regional chapters let you bring the AIF community offline. Meet up and be a part of a chapter near you.

Join a Chapter